Switching from one performance car to another often comes with a period of reflection, comparing the nuances of each machine. For those considering the jump from an Audi Rs5 to a BMW M3, understanding the real-world differences beyond the spec sheet is crucial. This review delves into a personal experience of owning a 2019 Audi RS5 4-door before making the move to an M3, offering insights into the strengths and weaknesses of the RS5, particularly for those in the market for a blend of luxury, sportiness, and everyday usability.
The Audi RS5 undeniably presents a compelling package. Its luxurious interior and sporty demeanor are immediately apparent. The all-wheel-drive system, a signature feature of Audi’s quattro technology, provides exceptional confidence, especially in challenging winter conditions. This was a primary draw for choosing the RS5 initially, offering a sense of security and control that’s invaluable in colder climates.
Furthermore, the practicality of the RS5’s hatchback design is a significant advantage. The generous cargo space easily accommodates weekend trips for a family or bulky items like sports equipment. This versatility makes the RS5 a surprisingly adaptable vehicle for daily life, blending performance with family-friendly functionality.
However, when it comes to the sheer thrill of driving, the RS5 experience, while enjoyable, doesn’t quite reach the heights of the BMW M3. As one owner articulated, driving an M3 “feels like an event” every time. This emotional connection and engaging driving dynamic were missing in the RS5. While the RS5’s powertrain is undoubtedly solid and capable, it lacks the raw excitement and feedback that the M3 delivers in spades. The interior of the RS5, while nicely appointed, can also feel somewhat understated, especially in darker color schemes, lacking the more driver-focused and visceral feel of the M3’s cockpit.
Reliability also became a significant concern during the RS5 ownership experience. Recurring issues, including multiple exhaust replacements and electronic malfunctions, led to frequent dealership visits. While these issues might be specific to individual vehicles, they understandably detract from the overall ownership satisfaction and raise questions about long-term dependability.
Despite these drawbacks, the RS5 holds its own in the aesthetics department. Many find the RS5 to be the more visually refined and “beautiful” car, while the M3 leans towards a more aggressively styled and “rugged handsome” appearance. This subjective aspect of car ownership often plays a crucial role in the buying decision, and the RS5’s elegant design is certainly a strong selling point.
Ultimately, the decision between an Audi RS5 and a BMW M3 comes down to priorities. The RS5 excels in blending luxury, all-weather capability, and practicality in a stylish package. However, for drivers who prioritize an emotionally engaging and dynamically superior driving experience, the BMW M3, particularly the newer all-wheel-drive models, presents a more compelling proposition. The dream car factor also cannot be ignored; for many, the M3 holds a special place in automotive desire that the RS5 simply doesn’t match. While updated RS5 models, including competition variants, are reported to offer improved performance, past reliability concerns might linger for some, making the M3 the more emotionally and practically sound choice for those seeking the ultimate driving thrill and a car that truly captures the heart.
