The Nissan Rogue. It’s a vehicle that often sits in the middle of the crossover SUV conversation, neither overwhelmingly praised nor heavily criticized. After spending some time behind the wheel of the latest model, I found myself in a similar position – somewhere between love and… well, not quite hate, but definitely a bit perplexed. This Nissan Rogue Car And Driver experience highlighted why many find themselves questioning the true appeal of this undeniably practical, yet somewhat quirky, SUV.
On the surface, the Nissan Rogue presents itself as a competent daily driver. The visibility is commendable, the ride is reasonably comfortable, and the running costs appear to be on the affordable side. These are strong points for anyone seeking a dependable vehicle for everyday life.
However, there’s also a sense of over-styling that’s hard to ignore. While not venturing into “ugly” territory, the design language teeters on the edge for some, including myself. It leaves you wondering if the aesthetic choices truly enhance or detract from the overall package.
Does it sound like I have mixed feelings about the Rogue? Because I genuinely do. Let’s delve into the specifics and explore the full spectrum of pros and cons that come with the Nissan Rogue.
Unveiling the Pros and Cons of the Nissan Rogue: A Driver’s Perspective
The Nissan Rogue has established itself as a mainstay in the crossover SUV segment for a reason. For over a decade, various iterations of the Rogue have served reliably as daily drivers for countless individuals and families. While opinions on the newer models’ aesthetics may be divided compared to earlier designs, the Rogue remains a fundamentally sound choice for those prioritizing practicality in a compact SUV. Let’s break down the key advantages and disadvantages:
The Upsides: Why the Nissan Rogue Might Be Right for You
-
Reliability and Ease of Maintenance: As a mass-produced vehicle with a long production run, the Nissan Rogue benefits from readily available parts and widespread service networks. Regardless of the model year, finding maintenance or repair services for your Rogue across the United States is generally hassle-free. This accessibility contributes to lower running costs and peace of mind for owners.
-
Superior Outward Visibility: In a segment where compromised visibility is becoming increasingly common due to design trends, the Nissan Rogue stands out with excellent outward visibility. Despite somewhat smaller windows than some might prefer, the Rogue’s design minimizes blind spots, offering a confident view of your surroundings. Navigating traffic and parking become less stressful thanks to this thoughtful design element.
-
Stylish Heritage (Subjective, Yet a Plus for Some): Interestingly, the Rogue’s styling can be both a pro and a con, depending on personal taste. Earlier Rogue models, in particular, are considered by many to be quite stylish. Nissan’s bold design philosophy is applied across their lineup, and the Rogue is no exception. While the author’s review of the 2023 Nissan Rogue expresses reservations about the exterior styling, the older generations hold a certain appeal for many.
-
Value for Money Proposition: The Nissan Rogue consistently delivers a level of perceived luxury and features that often surpass expectations for its price point. Drivers are often pleasantly surprised by the features and comfort offered in a vehicle within this competitive price bracket. This makes the Rogue an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers seeking a well-equipped SUV.
-
Ideal for Road Trips: The Nissan Rogue is well-suited for long journeys. The elevated seating position, coupled with the aforementioned excellent outward visibility, creates a comfortable and commanding driving experience for road trips. These factors contribute to reduced driver fatigue and enhanced enjoyment on extended drives.
-
Decent Reliability (Within the Nissan Context): While not topping reliability charts across all brands, the Nissan Rogue holds its own in terms of dependability, especially when considering Nissan’s broader reputation. It’s reliable enough to avoid constant headaches and unexpected breakdowns, providing a reasonably dependable ownership experience.
-
Adequate Performance: The Nissan Rogue isn’t designed to be a performance SUV, but it’s certainly not underpowered. Drivers generally find the engine options to be sufficient for daily driving needs. While not fast, the Rogue offers adequate acceleration and responsiveness for typical urban and highway driving. Pro Tip: Opting for the larger engine variant, when available, can enhance the driving experience with a bit more power on tap.
It’s interesting to imagine what onlookers thought as I pulled over to capture this shot. Perhaps they assumed I was preparing to list it for sale, but the truth is, the Rogue does have its appealing aspects!
The elevated driving position and decent visibility certainly have their advantages. While not typically drawn to trucks, SUVs, or crossovers, experiencing features like this in the Rogue and even in reviews of the Toyota Tacoma pros and cons, makes one reconsider preferences.
The 170hp 2.5L 4-cylinder engine in the 2018 Rogue felt appropriately powered for a crossover of this size. Interestingly, newer models feature smaller engines that paradoxically produce more horsepower. While counterintuitive, the result is still satisfactory performance.
It’s not a joke about the smaller engine size! This is indeed the 1.5L three-cylinder engine in the 2023 model. While seemingly diminutive, it provides sufficient power for the vehicle’s purpose.
Is it aesthetically pleasing or not? The design can be polarizing. Ultimately, deciding on the exterior styling is a matter of personal preference.
However, the interior is a different story. The interior design and comfort are genuinely appealing. Long cross-country road trips in these seats wouldn’t be a problem at all.
The Downsides: Potential Drawbacks of the Nissan Rogue
-
Questionable Styling (Again, Subjective): As mentioned, the Rogue’s “stylishness” can be a double-edged sword. Nissan’s aggressive design language isn’t universally appealing. The Rogue stands out as one of the more boldly styled SUVs in its class, which may not resonate with drivers who prefer a more understated aesthetic or want to blend in rather than stand out.
-
Inconsistent Build Quality: A recurring theme across Nissan Rogue models over the past decade has been concerns about build quality. Rattles, squeaks, and trim pieces detaching are not uncommon issues reported by owners. Finding a Rogue completely free of minor build quality imperfections can be challenging.
-
Limited Rear Seat Space for its Class: While not entirely cramped, the rear seats in the Nissan Rogue are somewhat tight for an SUV in this size category. While usable, full-sized adult passengers might find the rear accommodations less spacious than expected, especially on longer trips.
-
Soft Suspension Tuning (Especially Older Models): The suspension tuning, particularly in earlier Rogue models, tends to be on the softer side. For some drivers, this can lead to excessive body roll in corners and a less controlled feeling, potentially even inducing motion sickness on winding roads. While newer models have slightly tightened up the suspension, the Rogue still prioritizes comfort over sporty handling. The 2018 model driven in mountainous terrain highlighted this softness, becoming noticeable after a couple of hours of driving.
-
Lacking “Wow” Factor: The Nissan Rogue is unlikely to turn heads or elicit envy. For those seeking validation through their vehicle choice, the Rogue might be underwhelming. It’s a competent and practical vehicle, but it doesn’t possess the kind of distinctive character or prestige that makes it particularly memorable or aspirational. In the automotive landscape, the Rogue is decidedly unremarkable in terms of standing out.
The climate control and infotainment systems appear modern, but the potential for buzzing and rattling from plastic components on rough roads is a concern. This may not be the ideal vehicle for those with sensitivity to such noises or who frequently drive on poorly maintained roads.
The start button placement in the 2018 model is… unique. Thankfully, Nissan relocated it to a more conventional and ergonomic position in newer iterations.
The rear seating area can be surprisingly compact for a vehicle of this size class. Even apparel seems to express its disapproval of the limited space.
“Phantom” tires? The tire choice might hint at cost-cutting measures in the suspension and overall driving dynamics. The ride tends to be soft and somewhat lacking in precision.
Compelling Reasons to Consider a Nissan Rogue Purchase
Even after weighing the pros and cons, deciding on the Nissan Rogue can be challenging. However, if you’re still on the fence, consider this: the Rogue is a perfectly adequate vehicle for daily driving, and it’s unlikely to evoke strong negative feelings. Here are two compelling reasons to lean towards a purchase:
1. It’s Anything But Bland
Regardless of your personal opinion on Nissan’s design direction, the Rogue undeniably possesses a distinctive and “interesting” visual presence.
It’s certainly not the most visually offensive vehicle on the road. For many, purchasing an SUV is a practical necessity rather than an emotional indulgence. Choosing one with some assertive design elements, like the Rogue, can inject a bit more personality into a pragmatic vehicle segment. The Rogue strikes a balance, conveying “I’m practical, but not entirely devoid of personality.”
2. Drive it Without Hesitation
The Nissan Rogue may not be the reliability champion in its class, but it’s reliable enough for most drivers’ needs. Furthermore, its mass-market production and straightforward engineering mean servicing is widely accessible and affordable. Parts are relatively inexpensive, and specialized expertise isn’t required for routine maintenance. The Rogue encourages a “drive it and don’t worry too much” mentality. Address issues as they arise, and otherwise, enjoy its functionality.
Go ahead, load it up with whatever you need to haul! It’s just a Rogue; it’s replaceable and easily repairable if needed.
Reasons Why the Nissan Rogue Might Not Be Your Best Choice
Personal preferences play a significant role in car buying decisions. If it were my choice, the Nissan Rogue wouldn’t be at the top of my list. Not because it’s a fundamentally flawed vehicle, but simply because the highly competitive crossover SUV segment offers alternatives that might be more appealing. Even if my opinion doesn’t sway you, consider these points against choosing a Rogue:
1. It’s Still a Nissan
While I have fond memories of a 2004 Nissan 350Z, which remains one of my favorite cars, Nissan’s long-term durability isn’t their strongest suit.
While perfectly adequate in its early years, a Nissan Rogue, like many Nissans, is likely to show its age and potentially develop more significant issues as it approaches the 10-year mark, regardless of meticulous maintenance.
This isn’t intended to actively discourage you from considering a Rogue – it’s a decent daily driver – but the lack of an inspiring caption for this image perhaps speaks volumes about its overall impact.
2. You Might Experience Buyer’s Remorse
One of the main challenges for the Nissan Rogue isn’t inherent to the vehicle itself, but rather its position in a fiercely competitive market segment. Once the initial excitement of a new car purchase subsides, you might find yourself wondering if you made the optimal choice.
The crossover SUV market is rich with compelling alternatives, and you might start to explore other options and second-guess your decision after owning a Rogue for a while. This is a common human tendency in consumer choices.
If you’re prone to second-guessing significant purchases, it’s especially important to conduct thorough research beforehand to ensure you’re selecting the SUV that truly aligns with your long-term needs and desires. The Rogue, while competent, might not be the vehicle to completely eliminate that lingering “what if?” feeling.
