For those of us constantly evaluating our next automotive purchase, the 2023 Mini Cooper S Clubman ALL4 presents a unique proposition. In a market saturated with crossovers and SUVs, the Clubman S dares to be different, offering a refreshing take on practicality and driving enjoyment. It’s a vehicle that might not immediately spring to mind, especially with Mini’s reputation for retro styling, but the Clubman S has an undeniable charm and a distinct lack of direct competitors that makes it surprisingly compelling. Could this be the Goldilocks choice in the Mini lineup, and perhaps even your next car? Let’s delve into what makes the Mini Cooper Clubman S stand out.
This isn’t another crossover masquerading as something else. The Mini Cooper Clubman S proudly wears the badge of a wagon, or a long hatchback, a body style increasingly rare in today’s automotive landscape. For wagon enthusiasts, this alone is a reason to celebrate. Wagons inherently offer a superior driving experience compared to crossovers, providing the same cargo capacity and versatility without the compromised handling and higher center of gravity. While the ride in the Clubman S can be firm, a characteristic shared across most of the Mini range excluding the Countryman SUV, it’s a trade-off for the sporty and engaging driving dynamics that Mini is known for.
Adding to its appeal, the tested Mini Cooper S Clubman ALL4 came equipped with the ALL4 all-wheel-drive system. While the test conditions didn’t demand extreme traction, the availability of AWD adds another layer of confidence and capability, especially for those in regions with varied weather conditions. If you’re seeking a Mini for track days, the Clubman S might not be the prime choice, but for daily commutes and spirited drives on winding roads, it strikes a delightful balance between fun and functionality. It’s a car that encourages you to take the scenic route, to embrace “The Long Way Home.”
The review model sported the “Untold Special Edition” trim, one of Mini’s many distinctive packages. While the name might be easily forgotten amidst Mini’s extensive special editions, the aesthetic impact is undeniable. The Untold Edition features a striking Sage Green paintwork contrasted with sophisticated bronze trim accents on the front and rear, as well as on the wheels. This unique color combination might divide opinions, but it certainly commands attention and adds to the Clubman S’s distinctive personality.
Interestingly, the Mini Cooper Clubman model has been discontinued in Canada, leaving our northern neighbors to admire it from afar. While official reasons remain, one might speculate about the practicality of the signature barn-door rear hatch in colder climates or for typical Canadian cargo, like hockey equipment. The barn doors, while visually distinctive and charmingly retro, do present a slight compromise in everyday usability.
Indeed, the barn doors are perhaps the most noteworthy quirk of the Mini Cooper Clubman S. Accessing the rear cargo area requires opening two separate doors, which can be less convenient than a traditional liftgate, especially in tight parking spaces. In a confined garage, unloading groceries could become a slightly more involved process if space is limited behind the vehicle. While the Mini’s compact size mitigates some of this, it’s a factor to consider for potential owners.
Beyond the barn doors, the Mini Cooper Clubman S excels as a daily driver. Interior comfort is commendable in both the front and rear seats. A particularly welcome feature is the adjustable-length lower seat bolster, a testament to BMW’s influence and consideration for drivers of various sizes. The infotainment system is generally intuitive to operate, although the console-mounted control knob might initially feel counter-intuitive for some users, particularly when navigating satellite radio. However, this minor adjustment period typically fades quickly with regular use.
The Mini Cooper S Clubman ALL4, despite its larger size compared to the classic Mini, retains the playful spirit and engaging driving dynamics that define the brand. It’s a modern interpretation that honors its heritage while offering a unique blend of practicality and fun in a distinctive wagon format. The 2023 Mini Cooper Clubman S, with its quirky charm and uncommon body style, stands as a compelling and intriguing option for those seeking something different in the compact car segment.
2023 Mini Cooper S Clubman ALL4: Fast Facts
Powertrain: 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder (189hp @ 5,000rpm, 206 lb-ft @ 1,350rpm)
Transmission: Eight-speed automatic transmission, all-wheel drive
Fuel Economy, MPG (EPA Rating): 23 city / 32 highway / 27 combined
Base Price (US): $37,350
Price as Tested (US): $44,400
(Prices include $850 destination charge in the United States. Clubman model no longer available in Canada.)
