Looking for a versatile and economical vehicle? Crossovers have become a popular choice, blending the practicality of an SUV with the driving dynamics of a car. If fuel efficiency is high on your priority list, you might be surprised to learn that there are numerous used crossover options available that offer excellent gas mileage. It’s an ideal time to consider upgrading to a more efficient vehicle, and the used market is brimming with choices. To help you navigate this landscape, we’ve compiled a list of 10 used crossovers renowned for their impressive fuel economy, originally highlighted by Autobytel editors. Explore these models to discover a used crossover that not only fits your lifestyle but also saves you money at the pump.
1) 2012 Ford Escape Hybrid — 34/31 MPG
The 2012 Ford Escape Hybrid stands out with its EPA-estimated fuel economy of 34 MPG in the city and 31 MPG on the highway, making it a top contender in the realm of fuel-efficient used crossovers. This model year marked the end of its production, featuring a robust powertrain that combined a 155-horsepower gasoline engine with a 94-horsepower electric motor. This pairing delivered brisk acceleration and commendable fuel savings. While noted for its fuel efficiency, some reviews at the time pointed out the less refined interior materials. For those considering this option, the Mercury Mariner Hybrid, sharing the same platform and fuel economy, is worth exploring. Though discontinued in 2010, including the Mariner in your search can broaden your options in terms of price and vehicle condition.
2) 2015 Subaru XV Crosstrek Hybrid — 30/34 MPG
Subaru vehicles are generally recognized for their efficiency, especially considering their standard all-wheel-drive systems. The Subaru XV Crosstrek Hybrid is a prime example, boasting EPA ratings of 30 MPG in city driving and 34 MPG on the highway. This hybrid crossover provides 160 horsepower from its gas-electric powertrain and offers all-weather capability, making it a practical choice for various climates. While often categorized as a crossover, the Crosstrek Hybrid leans towards a wagon-like design, which may result in slightly less cargo space compared to more traditional crossovers. Nevertheless, its fuel efficiency and Subaru’s renowned reliability make it a strong contender among used crossovers with good gas mileage.
3) 2014 MINI Cooper Countryman — 28/35 MPG
MINI Coopers aren’t typically associated with fuel efficiency, but the 2014 MINI Cooper Countryman can be an exception. This compact crossover SUV achieves up to 28 MPG in the city and an impressive 35 MPG on the highway, securing its place on this list of used crossovers with the best gas mileage. However, these figures are specific to the base model, which produces 121 horsepower, and are achieved only with the manual transmission. It’s also worth noting that the MINI Cooper Countryman requires premium fuel, which could offset some of the fuel cost savings. Despite this, for those seeking MINI’s distinctive style combined with better fuel economy, the Countryman is a compelling option.
4) 2015 Nissan Juke — 28/34 MPG
The Nissan Juke, a distinctive and quirky hatchback SUV, stands out on this list of fuel-efficient crossovers due to its unique styling and engaging driving dynamics. It’s powered by a turbocharged 1.6-liter 4-cylinder engine producing 188 horsepower, offering a spirited performance that’s both fun and efficient. When paired with its continuously variable transmission (CVT), the Juke achieves EPA fuel economy ratings of 28 MPG city and 34 MPG highway. Similar to the MINI, the Juke requires premium gasoline, which is something to consider in your fuel budget, though it contributes to the engine’s performance and efficiency.
5) 2015 BMW X3 — 27/34 MPG
For buyers seeking a luxury used crossover that doesn’t compromise on fuel efficiency, the BMW X3 is an excellent choice. It’s among the more upscale options listed, and particularly efficient in xDrive28d trim, achieving 27 MPG city and 34 MPG highway with its optional 180-horsepower turbodiesel engine. The xDrive28d model comes standard with all-wheel drive and a host of available luxury features. The BMW X3 xDrive28d presents a well-rounded package of luxury, performance, and fuel economy. If the diesel variant is less readily available, the base model X3 also offers respectable fuel mileage and may be easier to find on the used market.
6) 2015 Honda CR-V — 27/34 MPG
Honda’s reliable and popular CR-V is a strong contender on this list of used crossovers with the best gas mileage. This compact SUV is appreciated for its overall value, encompassing performance, features, and passenger comfort, along with EPA fuel economy ratings reaching 27 MPG in city driving and 34 MPG on the highway. The CR-V’s standard 4-cylinder engine, producing 185 horsepower, prioritizes fuel efficiency over outright speed, a worthwhile trade-off for many drivers. The 2015 model year introduced a more fuel-efficient continuously variable transmission, replacing the traditional automatic, which further enhanced fuel economy. However, even older CR-V models remain a solid choice for fuel-conscious buyers.
7) 2015 Mazda CX-5 — 26/35 MPG
The Mazda CX-5 is another used crossover that masterfully blends driving enjoyment with excellent fuel economy. Its engaging driving experience stems from its agile handling, making it feel more nimble than its size suggests. Even with the standard 155-horsepower 4-cylinder engine, the CX-5 is fun to drive due to its responsive steering and cornering. For those desiring more power, an optional 184-horsepower 4-cylinder engine is available, with only a minor decrease of 1 MPG in city fuel economy. If your budget allows for the larger engine, it’s a worthwhile upgrade in this fuel-efficient used crossover.
8) 2015 Nissan Rogue — 26/33 MPG
Nissan secures another spot on this list with the Rogue, a compact SUV offering a more conventional style compared to the Juke, while still delivering on practicality and fuel efficiency. The Rogue provides a slightly more premium feel than many competitors in its class, without sacrificing versatility. Its 170-horsepower 4-cylinder engine offers adequate power for everyday driving, while maintaining commendable fuel efficiency, rated at 26 MPG city and 33 MPG highway. The Rogue comfortably seats five passengers and offers a more refined interior than expected at its price point.
9) 2015 Buick Encore — 25/33 MPG
The Buick Encore demonstrates that you can find used crossovers with excellent gas mileage without forgoing upscale features and comfort. The Encore, with its 138-horsepower engine, achieves EPA fuel economy of up to 25 MPG in the city and 33 MPG on the highway in front-wheel-drive configurations. The cabin is surprisingly spacious for its size, providing adequate rear-seat room for adults, and the ride is known for being smooth and quiet. Older Encore models offer similar fuel efficiency, but the 2015 model adds a standard mobile Wi-Fi hotspot, a desirable feature for many buyers.
10) 2009 Saturn VUE Hybrid — 25/32 MPG
Concluding our list of used crossovers with the best gas mileage, the 2009 Saturn VUE Hybrid is a noteworthy, though less common, option. If you’re budget-conscious and seeking a hybrid crossover, the Saturn VUE Hybrid is worth considering, even despite the brand being discontinued. The Saturn VUE Hybrid is a versatile and pleasant vehicle to drive, offering fuel economy ratings of 25 MPG city and 32 MPG highway. It represents a rare hybrid choice in the used crossover market dominated by traditional gasoline engines, providing a unique blend of efficiency and value.
